Short answer: asphalt shingles cost far less up front, and metal lasts longer. This Old House lists average costs of about $7 per square foot for shingles and $28 per square foot for metal in 2026, or roughly $14,000 vs. $56,000 for a 2,000 sq ft roof. Architectural shingles typically last about 30 years; a well-maintained metal roof can last up to 50 years, and sometimes much longer. For most New Jersey homeowners who plan to stay 10 to 25 years, shingles are the better value. Metal makes more sense if you’ll stay for decades and can afford the higher upfront cost.
How much more does a metal roof cost than shingles?
Usually a lot more, but how much depends on the type of metal and whose numbers you use. Cost guides vary widely and don’t always say whether labor is included, so treat these as ballpark national figures, not a quote:
| Roof type | Approximate cost per sq ft (sources differ on what’s included) | Typical lifespan |
|---|---|---|
| Basic 3-tab asphalt shingles | About $5 average (This Old House) | 15 to 20 years (This Old House) |
| Architectural asphalt shingles | About $7 average (This Old House) | About 30 years (This Old House) |
| Steel roofing | About $20 average (This Old House); $6 to $16 (NerdWallet, materials) | Up to 50 years, sometimes much longer |
| Standing seam metal | $8 to $14 (NerdWallet, materials) | Up to 50 years, sometimes much longer |
| Aluminum | About $21 average (This Old House); $8 to $12 (NerdWallet, materials) | Up to 50 years, sometimes much longer |
| Copper | About $35 average (This Old House); $16 to $30 (NerdWallet, materials) | Up to 50 years, sometimes much longer |
Lifespans for metal come from NerdWallet, which says metal roofs last as long as 50 years and sometimes over 100, and This Old House, which says up to 100 years with good maintenance. For local shingle pricing and what drives a quote up or down, see how much a new roof costs in NJ.
Is metal cheaper in the long run?
Only if you stay long enough. Here’s a simple way to compare, using the This Old House averages for a 2,000 sq ft roof:
- Architectural shingles: about $14,000 over about 30 years works out to roughly $467 per year.
- A metal roof at about $56,000 would need to last around 120 years to match that cost per year.
That doesn’t count repairs, resale value or what you’d pay for a second shingle roof down the line, but it shows why the “metal pays for itself” pitch depends heavily on the price you’re quoted and how long you’ll own the house.

How do metal and shingles compare on everything else?
| Factor | Asphalt shingles | Metal |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Lower | Much higher |
| Lifespan | About 15 to 30 years depending on quality | Up to 50 years, sometimes much longer, with maintenance |
| Repairs | Damaged shingles can be swapped individually | Panel repairs are more specialized; NerdWallet notes expansion and contraction can loosen fasteners |
| Noise | Quiet | Rain and hail can be loud, though NerdWallet notes there are ways to soften it |
| Dents | Hail can bruise or knock granules off | Some metals dent from hail or falling branches (NerdWallet) |
| Energy | Standard dark shingles absorb heat | Light or “cool” coatings reflect sun; benefit is biggest in hot climates (DOE) |
| Look and rules | Fits most NJ neighborhoods | Some HOAs restrict metal roofing (NerdWallet) |
Is metal better for New Jersey snow and ice dams?
Metal sheds snow more easily than shingles, especially on steeper slopes. Many metal roofs get snow guards so snow doesn’t slide off in one sheet onto walkways, steps or cars. But the roofing material doesn’t fix the cause of ice dams. Ice dams form when heat leaking into the attic melts snow that refreezes at the eaves, so the real fix is air sealing, insulation and ventilation. See our guides to ice dams in New Jersey and how much attic ventilation a roof needs.
Will a metal roof lower my energy bills in NJ?
Maybe a little in summer, but don’t count on big savings. The U.S. Department of Energy’s consumer guide to cool roofs says the savings from reflective “cool” roofs are greatest in hot and warm climates, and that a cool roof may increase heating needs in winter. North Jersey, including Bergen, Passaic, Morris and Sussex counties, sits in a cold climate zone, so the winter penalty counts for more here than in hot states. Energy savings alone aren’t a strong reason to choose metal in this area.
So which should you choose?
- Choose architectural shingles if you want the best value for a typical ownership period, easy repairs, and a look that matches most North Jersey streets.
- Consider metal if you plan to stay for decades, want to avoid another roof replacement, have a low-slope section like a porch, or simply prefer the look, and the quote fits your budget.
- Either way, the installation and the condition of the deck and ventilation matter as much as the material. Ask what warranty comes with the roof and get it in writing. Our guide to roof warranties explains what to look for.

Frequently asked questions
How long do asphalt shingles last in New Jersey?
Roughly 15 to 30 years, depending on the shingle and how well the attic is ventilated. Our guide to how long a roof lasts in New Jersey goes through each material.
Is a metal roof louder in the rain?
It can be, especially in heavy rain or hail. NerdWallet notes the noise can be softened, and how loud it sounds inside depends a lot on what’s under the metal and whether there’s a finished attic.
Can I use metal on just part of my roof?
Yes. Metal on a porch, bay window or low section with shingles on the main roof is a common combination, like the porch roof shown above.
Not sure which roof is right for your home?
We’ll look at your roof, talk through your options and give you a clear written quote. Better Built Construction serves homeowners across North and Central New Jersey. Call (201) 598-0336 or request a free quote. Learn more about our roof replacement service.
About Better Built Construction
This guide was written by the roofing team at Better Built Construction, a family-owned roofing and exterior contractor based at 50 Lisbon St, Clifton, NJ 07013. We repair and replace roofs, flat roofs, siding and skylights for homes and businesses across North and Central New Jersey, with 24/7 emergency service. Licensed and insured. NJ HIC Reg. #13VH10432600
Sources: This Old House, “Shingles vs. Metal Roof Cost” (updated 2026); NerdWallet, “Metal Roof Cost”; New Jersey Department of Community Affairs, Bulletin 22-1 (climate zones); U.S. Department of Energy, “Consumer Guide to Cool Roofs.”